Expand description
STIT agency — “α Sees To It That φ” (Phase 3, DEONTIC_LOGIC_PLAN §5).
Standard deontic logic makes states of affairs obligatory (O(φ)). Legal instruments
make specific agents obligated to act (“the State shall ensure…”). STIT binds the
deontic force to the agent who is the causal force, which lets the engine:
- distinguish a duty-bearer from a bystander (
is_duty_bearer); - detect omission — an in-force obligation the bearer did not bring about
(
agentive_status→Violated); and - model joint action / shared liability —
O[{α,β} stit φ]discharged iff any member brings φ about, else all members share liability (joint_discharged,joint_liable_members).
A STIT-bound norm reuses the deontic norm Quin: subject is the agent α (the causal
force), object is the brought-about content φ. The causal fact convention is
(α, q42:broughtAbout, φ). This module is a post-hoc accountability reading over a
deontic norm (evaluated when the duty is due/closed), complementing the live-status
deontic::norm_lifecycle_status. Zero-heap throughout.
Functions§
- agentive_
status - Post-hoc accountability status of an agentive norm
O[α stit φ]/F[α stit φ], evaluated when the duty is due/closed: - brought_
about - Did
agentsee to it thatcontent— i.e. is the causal fact(agent, q42:broughtAbout, content)present? - chellas_
stit - Chellas STIT
[α cstit φ]: α saw to it that φ — here, α brought φ about. - could_
have_ prevented - Counterfactual omission (“could have prevented X but did not”): the agent had the
abilityand theopportunityto bring about the prevention, yet did not act. The counterfactual that turns a bare omission into a culpable one. - deliberative_
stit - Deliberative STIT
[α dstit φ]: α brought φ about AND φ was not settled (α could have done otherwise) — the genuine-choice reading that grounds moral responsibility. - is_
duty_ bearer - True iff
agentis the bearer (causal subject) of the agentive norm — a duty-bearer rather than a bystander. (Accountability: the obligation attaches to the actor, not to everyone who could have acted.) - is_
settled - Is φ settled — true on all histories (the agent had no real choice)?
could_do_otherwiseis whether an alternative history avoided φ. - joint_
discharged - Joint obligation
O[{members} stit φ]: discharged iff any member saw to it that φ (joint sufficiency). Zero-heap. - joint_
liable_ members - Shared liability: if the joint obligation is NOT discharged, every member shares
liability — write them into
outand return the count. Returns0when discharged (no one is liable). Zero-heap (caller-suppliedout).