Expand description
Contextual Assertions, Provenance, Verification, and Challenge Model.
Implements C:\github\license\CONTEXTUAL-ASSERTIONS.md:
StatementType:Observation,Inference,Allegation,Attestation,AdjudicatedFindingAssertionStatus:Active,Challenged,Restricted,Expired,Withdrawn,SupersededVerificationStatus:Proposed,Attested,Verified,Disputed,Adjudicated
Core invariants enforced by pure validation functions:
- Single-Source Inference Deduplication & No Auto-Promotion: Repetition or multiple
dependent inferences sharing a
root_source_idnever count as independent corroboration and never auto-promote anAllegationorInferenceinto anAdjudicatedFindingorObservation. - Challenge Preservation & Downstream Review: Challenging an assertion preserves both the challenged assertion and the challenge record, and marks all downstream dependent decisions for review.
- Zero Universal Human Reputation Score: Assertions remain scoped to their specific domain/context; deriving a collapsed scalar human reputation score is rejected.
Structs§
- Challenge
Record - Formal challenge filed against an assertion (
CONTEXTUAL-ASSERTIONS.md§5). - Contextual
Assertion - A contextual, provenance-anchored statement (
CONTEXTUAL-ASSERTIONS.md§4). - Downstream
Decision Ref - Downstream governance, accounting, or eligibility decision that depends on one or more assertions.
Enums§
- Assertion
Status - Lifecycle state of an assertion (
CONTEXTUAL-ASSERTIONS.md§3). - Statement
Type - Epistemic category of a contextual statement (
CONTEXTUAL-ASSERTIONS.md§2). - Verification
Status - Verification posture of an assertion (
CONTEXTUAL-ASSERTIONS.md§3).
Functions§
- apply_
assertion_ challenge - Apply a
ChallengeRecordagainsttarget_assertion_id: - count_
independent_ corroborations - Count independent corroborating sources across a slice of assertions.
Multiple assertions or dependent inferences sharing a
root_source_idcount at most ONCE, andWithdrawnorExpiredassertions are excluded. - validate_
assertion_ promotion - Validate a proposed transition in
StatementTypeorVerificationStatus: - validate_
contextual_ evaluation_ scope - Enforce the anti-universal-reputation rule (
CONTEXTUAL-ASSERTIONS.md§1.4 & §4.5): Zero universal human reputation score or cross-context scalar person ranking may ever be derived.